How to tell if a photo is AI-generated

Six checks, in the order that actually helps: first the source, then your first impression, then the details that generators still get wrong. No single check is proof — but together they lead to a well-founded judgement.

Last updated: October 2026 6 min read

Start with the source, not the pixels

Before you zoom into anything, ask where the image came from. Who posted it, and does the caption match what you see? A reverse image search shows you earlier versions of the same picture: if it turns up in many unrelated posts with different stories attached, it is usually circulating as a hoax rather than as a photo with a traceable origin.

This step takes about ten seconds and clears up more misleading images than any pixel-level clue. A large share of pictures that people suspect to be AI-generated turn out to be genuine photos with a false caption.

Keep in mind: A missing origin is not proof of AI. Anonymous accounts post real photos too, and many news images are used without the original context.

The first impression: thirty seconds, no zooming

At normal viewing size, AI images often look “too tidy” in a specific way: every object is fully visible, the light is even and flattering, the background is pleasantly soft, and nothing is accidentally cut off. Real snapshots contain disorder — a half-eaten plate, a tangle of cables, a stranger's arm at the edge of the frame, harsh light from a window.

A staged look is a reason to look closer, not a verdict. Good photographers compose exactly like that on purpose, and product photos are cleaned up even more.

Zoom into the weak spots

Open the image at full size and go through the places where a generator has to keep many rules consistent at the same time. These are still the most productive spots for clues:

  • Hands, fingernails and the way fingers meet objects
  • Hair edges, teeth and ears where the head meets the background
  • Text on signs, screens and clothing
  • Reflections in windows, mirrors, water and sunglasses
  • Faces in the background of a crowd
  • Small fasteners: glasses, straps, buttons, jewellery
practise these checks in the AI or real quiz

Keep in mind: Current generators handle many of these well. A missing clue never means “real” — it only means this particular check did not help.

Check whether the scene obeys physics

Light and shadow are the most reliable checks. Find the brightest area, work out where the light must be coming from, then check whether all the shadows point away from that direction and whether reflections show what should actually be reflected.

Then look for impossible geometry: a chair that merges into a table, a window that opens onto a solid wall, two objects made of the same material but with different sharpness, steps that lead nowhere. A camera records what happened to be in front of it; a generator produces what usually looks right.

Use tools as hints, not as verdicts

Metadata (EXIF) can name a camera and a date, but it is easy to strip or fake, and most social platforms delete it on upload. AI detectors return a probability, nothing more: they often miss the newest models and sometimes flag edited real photos.

The one thing that is actually verifiable is a content credential (C2PA): signed information about how an image was created or edited. Very few images carry it today, but if you see it, it is worth trusting.

Why modern AI images are hard to tell apart

Generators are trained on billions of photographs, and every mistake that becomes well known gets trained away. So whether you can tell if a picture is AI-generated depends less on the picture than on the scene: a fantasy landscape gives itself away, a photo of a kitchen counter does not.

The hard cases are styled on purpose to look like snapshots. In our own hard mode the images are built to mimic film grain, slight underexposure and candid framing — exactly the imperfections people use as evidence of authenticity.

That is why the number of correct guesses is not a fixed skill. It moves with the models, with the scene and with the resolution you are looking at.

Keep in mind: So “I cannot tell” is often the most accurate answer, and naming that honestly is better than forcing a verdict.

A worked example, step by step

Take the neon city example from our quiz. First look: a night street full of glowing signs. Second look: the lettering looks like writing but forms no readable word in any language. Third look: no real city matches the layout, and invented places are a fast hint. The reasoning took seconds because it never depended on fine detail.

Now the opposite case, a bicycle leaning in a narrow alley: worn paint, rust at the frame joints, a casually cropped wall and a shadow that matches the one visible light source. Nothing is tidied up. Real — not because it looks good, but because the disorder is consistent.

see these examples with the images in the AI or real quiz

Keep in mind: Both examples are read with the same procedure: subject first, then text, then light and geometry. A clue is only ever the reason to look again.

Give an honest confidence level

Instead of a simple true or false, use four levels: certainly AI, probably AI, unsure, probably real. For “certainly AI” you want a hard contradiction — impossible anatomy, unreadable gibberish text, shadows pointing in two directions at once.

“I can't tell” is a legitimate result, and at high difficulty it is often the correct one. That is exactly what our quiz measures: not whether you can always be right, but whether your judgement is well calibrated.

A single feature is not proof. Real photos also show smooth surfaces, blurry lettering and brightened shadows. Treat every clue as a reason to check origin and several observations together.

Dragon above a castleAI image

Dragon above a castle

The simplest case: you cannot photograph a dragon. When the subject is impossible you do not need to inspect details — the content decides. These are the easy rounds in the quiz.

AI image: generated for this project (media.base44.com)

Waterfall in the forestReal photo

Waterfall in the forest

Nothing is tidy here: spray, wet rock and tangled vegetation follow physics without any clean-up. A messy, random-looking scene is what a camera in real light tends to produce.

Photo: Unsplash (curated shot from the quiz pool)

Mini quiz

Mini quiz: three quick judgements

Three situations from this guide. Choose an answer and the explanation follows immediately.

1. Where do you start with an unfamiliar image?

Frequently asked questions

Can I always see that an image is AI-generated?

No. Some images are unmistakable, many are not. Detection is not a fixed skill but a moving target: as soon as a typical mistake becomes well known, generators are trained to avoid it.

Is looking at the hands enough?

Rarely. Hands are a useful starting point because they follow strict rules, but real photos of moving hands are blurry and merged too. Clues only become convincing when several of them come together.

What is the fastest check?

Text. Signs, labels and screens in AI images often contain letters that look plausible but form no readable word — and unlike hands, text can be checked without any knowledge of photography.

Key takeaway

Check the source first, then your first impression, then the details: text, hands, light and reflections. One clue means “look closer”, not “proof”.

Practise with feedback

Every game has ten images: five real photos and five AI images. After each guess you see the answer, so you learn while you play. Free, no account needed.

Play the quiz

More guides

Wir nutzen lokalen Speicher für Betrieb, Sicherheit und Spielfortschritt. Mit „Alle akzeptieren" erlaubst du zusätzlich Werbung (Google AdSense), die Cookies setzen kann. Details in der Datenschutzerklärung.